Walk north along the restaurant stretch of South Osprey Avenue in Southside Village and the numbers climb in a tight run. Lucky 8 is at 1812. Legends Sports Pub is at 1816. The 1818 Grill had its own address in its name. A little farther along is 1830, the number used by Veronica Fish & Oyster and, until the last day of September, by Alma de España. On a short block like this, the people working one patio can see the next one.
Within five days in late September, two of those doors closed. The 1818 Grill served its last meal on Saturday, Sept. 26, and Alma de España closed its Osprey Avenue dining room on Sept. 30. Both handoffs stayed on the block. The 1818 Grill's owner was selling the business to the bar next door, and he was set to work for the chef who had been cooking two doors down. Two signs changed this fall, and nearly everyone involved is still tied to the row.
| Address | Business | Where things stand |
|---|---|---|
| 1812 S. Osprey Ave. | Lucky 8 | Open, with a 2026 Michelin Bib Gourmand |
| 1816 S. Osprey Ave. | Legends Sports Pub | Open, with plans to become a full bar and restaurant |
| 1818 S. Osprey Ave. | Former The 1818 Grill | Business being sold to the Siciliano family of Legends |
| 1830 S. Osprey Ave. | Veronica Fish & Oyster | Open for dinner, taking reservations |
| 1830 S. Osprey Ave. | Former Alma de España | Restaurant moved to 239 S. Links Ave. in Towles Court |
The address at 1818 S. Osprey has a long history of its own. It was Knick's Tavern & Grill starting in 2002. Tommy Lovell took over in 2024, and the name later changed to The 1818 Grill. When he decided to close, the Sarasota Herald-Tribune reported that he was selling the business to the Siciliano family, who own Legends Sports Pub right next door at 1816.
That changes what Legends can be. According to the same Herald-Tribune story, Legends had a beer and wine license and no food menu, and the plan is to expand it into a full bar and restaurant. If that happens, the pub that had been the beer-and-wine stop on the row becomes a place where people can sit down for a meal, in a kitchen space the block already knows. The Herald-Tribune's September openings and closings roundup described the expansion the same way, as a plan by the family next door.
Lovell explained the closing in plain kitchen terms. He told the Herald-Tribune that the summer off-season had been especially hard and that gas, produce, cooking oil and beef had all gotten more expensive. The clearest example was his weekend prime rib.
"In 2024 and 2025, I had a prime rib dinner every Friday and Saturday night and I couldn't afford it anymore — I could afford it, but I didn't want to pass those costs off to the customers," Lovell told the Herald-Tribune. "I couldn't justify a $50 prime rib dinner to try and make a little bit of money off that. My prime rib dinners were always around $37, $40, and I just didn't want to give that to the customer."
He had sold the plate for $37 to $40, could not justify charging $50 for it, and dropped the dish. When the Herald-Tribune asked if he had a final message, he said, "I would just love to thank the neighborhood."
Lovell's next step is the part of this fall's change that holds the row together. He stays in restaurants. The Herald-Tribune reported that he will join Alma de España, the Spanish tapas and grill restaurant that chef and owner Elier Rodriguez had opened a few doors away at 1830 S. Osprey, as general manager and sommelier at its new downtown location.
"I'm going to run his front of the house, and then I'm also going to be his sommelier, and I'm going to pour a great wine for him," Lovell told the Herald-Tribune. "Those are the parts and the pieces that I've loved in my restaurant over the years."
Alma de España opened in Southside Village in 2025, in the former Ka Papa Cuisine space. Rodriguez was born in Cuba and has said the restaurant was inspired by his grandmother, Cacha, whose cooking shaped his career. The Osprey Avenue menu included garlic prawns, Spanish-style octopus, paella and Basque-style branzino. Your Observer traces his training through Le Cordon Bleu College of Culinary Arts in Atlanta and kitchens including Le Cirque Las Vegas and The Fontainebleau Miami Beach. It also notes two years at Picasso inside the Bellagio, which earned two Michelin stars.
So a Southside Village regular who used to split their nights between the 1818 bar and Alma's tapas has seen the man who ran one of those rooms line up to run the floor and pour the wine at the other.
Alma's new home is 239 S. Links Ave. in Towles Court, the cottage that held Indigenous until that restaurant closed in mid-September. According to Your Observer, Sarasota County property records show the roughly 1,100-square-foot building sold on Sept. 28 for $1.65 million. The buyer was Cathedral Hospitality Holdings LLC, which state business filings register to Rodriguez, and the seller was Apex Property Holdings LLC.
The building was one reason for the move. The outdoor space was another. Rodriguez told the Herald-Tribune that Towles Court appealed to him because it had room outside for live music, played softly enough that diners could still talk. The restaurant announced a Nov. 1 grand opening at the Links Avenue address in a social media post the Herald-Tribune reported on. Your Observer described the plans for that night as live guitar and percussion, a flamenco performance, and Spanish tapas and cocktails, with a menu running from gazpacho to paella to flan that draws on both Spain and Cuba.
From Southside Village, Alma is no longer a stroll down Osprey. It is now a short drive or bike ride into downtown, where the Towles Court cottages sit near Links Avenue. The people are the same. Only the address has changed.
The two restaurants at either end of this stretch did not change this fall.
Lucky 8, at 1812 S. Osprey, is the New Orleans-inspired restaurant from chef and co-owner Mark Majorie. It earned a Michelin Guide Bib Gourmand earlier this year. In late October, the Herald-Tribune put it on its list of places to eat in Sarasota before tourist season fills the dining rooms. The Michelin Guide's listing shows lunch and dinner from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Monday through Thursday and until 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday, closed Sunday. Lucky 8 is also the daytime anchor of the row, since it opens at 11 a.m. and every other spot on this list is an evening place.
Veronica Fish & Oyster, Majorie's earlier restaurant, is still open at 1830 S. Osprey. Its own site lists dinner from 5 to 9 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and from 5 p.m. to midnight Friday and Saturday. Happy hour runs 5 to 6 p.m. in the dining room and 5 to 7 p.m. at the bar and lounge. It is the latest-open kitchen on the block on weekends, and with Veronica open Sundays and Lucky 8 closed, Veronica is the row's Sunday dinner option.
Restaurant hours tend to shift once season starts, so it's wise to check either restaurant's listing before you head out.
Put the pieces together and the stretch of Osprey that went into September with five businesses comes out of November with the same people in new roles. The 1818 Grill's business is going to the family that runs the bar beside it, and Legends has a path from beer and wine to a full kitchen. The 1818's owner is lined up to pour wine for the chef who used to be his neighbor, at that chef's new address on Links Avenue. Lucky 8 and Veronica Fish & Oyster are where they were, two restaurants on the same block that Majorie has cooked in.
For someone who lives in Southside Village, Hudson Bayou or Cherokee Park, the practical effect this winter is a slightly different evening route. Lunch and weeknight dinners on Osprey still run through Lucky 8 and Veronica. Spanish tapas now means heading downtown to Towles Court. And 1818 and 1816 are worth watching as the Sicilianos turn the Legends plan into a kitchen.
Juli Pearce works out of the Main Street office of Michael Saunders & Company, a short drive from both Osprey Avenue and Towles Court, and this fall she has been watching the row the same way her neighbors have. If you're thinking about life near a block like this one, where the restaurant owners take care of each other's spaces, she would be glad to compare notes over dinner on Osprey or a tapas plate on Links. Let's Connect with Juli Pearce.
Let Julianne guide you through Sarasota’s luxury real estate market with the expertise, insight, and personalized attention you deserve. From beachfront estates to serene golf course homes, your ideal Florida lifestyle is just a phone call away.